The Boy Must Be Bound Out Of Hand

Reference Great Expectations, chapter 13

Context: Towards the end of the chapter, after their return home from Miss Havisham's there is a discussion among Mrs Joe, Joe, and uncle Pumblechook about the future of Pip.  Pumblechook says "the boy must be bound." 

The phrase means that Pip should be formally apprenticed to Joe Gargery as a blacksmith. Bound means legally bound by an apprenticeship agreement. 

In 19 century England, a boy entering a trade was commonly apprenticed through a formal agreement:  By this agreement the boy was bound to a master craftsman, who undertakes to teach him the trade. The boy was expected to serve the master for an agreed period, until he reached the adulthood.  The arrangement could be recorded in an indenture, a legal document.

There is an interesting social dimension here:

Pumblechook speaks as though he has authority over Pip's future.  Yet it was Joe, who was going to teach Pip the trade.  Pip himself has no.say in the decision.

Dickens is showing us how a child's future could be settled by.adults, through social institutions.  The irony: Pip begins to think beyond the forge.  The occassion is celebrated in domestic circle involving food and drinks.

There is an irony worth to take note:
• For Joe taking Pip as an apprentice is only a continuation of his own trade through Pip.
• For Mrs Joe it is an occasion of social recognition.
• For Mr Pumblechook it is a chance to take credit for having brought Pip's future.
• For Pip, this apprenticeship is not the future he looks forward.

There is a neurological dimension to our understanding of Pip.
The human brain does not mature all at once. Different regions develope at different rates.  One particularly important area is Prefrontal cortex.which.is associated with:

• Judgement and decision making.
• Impulse control.
• Planning and anticipating. consequences.
• Regulation of emotions.
• Assessing risks.
Brain's development continuea through adolescence and into twenties. 
The age 23 is sometimes as a convenient approximation, but modern neuroscience does not establish a precise age at which the brain is completely mature.  Development can continue into the mid-twenties and beyond.

Now consider Pip.
He is a child who encounters extraordinary circumstances:
• A terrifying encounter with the convict.
• A mysterious world of Satis House.
• Estella's humiliation of him.
• The sudden prospect of becoming a gentleman.
His emotional responses, curiosities, impulsiveness and changing ambitions need to be understood in the context of developing brain.

Mrs Joe's judgement is based on 19th century perception.  She expects adult-like self-control from a growing child.  She interprets developmental behaviour as a moral failing.

There is a larger point worth considering: Dickens was writing long before modern developmental neuroscience.  Yet his remarkable understanding of childhood allows us to read Pip in ways that neuroscience now helps explain.


Comments

Popular Posts